27 episodes

Hey fellow Sleuths! 
We are your hosts, Katie Kaplan, an award-winning investigative journalist, and Em, a former special agent and hostage negotiator. 
Together we are both passionate about helping to shed light on unsolved cases. We hope that together- with you the listener- we can help to bring awareness and closure to some of the people impacted by unsolved murders and disappearances. Someone, somewhere, knows something.
Let’s work together to put your interest in true crime to use! Log on anywhere you listen to podcasts and let’s get sleuthing!
Stay vigilant, and stay curious fellow sleuths.

Two Sleuths Katie Kaplan & Em

    • True Crime
    • 4.9 • 36 Ratings

Hey fellow Sleuths! 
We are your hosts, Katie Kaplan, an award-winning investigative journalist, and Em, a former special agent and hostage negotiator. 
Together we are both passionate about helping to shed light on unsolved cases. We hope that together- with you the listener- we can help to bring awareness and closure to some of the people impacted by unsolved murders and disappearances. Someone, somewhere, knows something.
Let’s work together to put your interest in true crime to use! Log on anywhere you listen to podcasts and let’s get sleuthing!
Stay vigilant, and stay curious fellow sleuths.

    The Secret Witness - Part 2

    The Secret Witness - Part 2

    Send us a Text Message.Welcome back Sleuths! In today's episode, we bring you the conclusion of The Secret Witness and discuss how police were finally able to overcome the obstacles facing them during the investigation into the murders of Averill Weeden, Dawn Berryhill, and Belinda Jo Stark.ANNOUNCEMENT:We will not be releasing an episode next week due to a family emergency. In the meantime go give Katie some love and let her know you all are thinking about her! @KatiekaplanTV.We will be back...

    • 35 min
    The Secret Witness - Part 1

    The Secret Witness - Part 1

    Send us a Text Message.A bearded motorcyclist who had the habit of killing women. And- he believed the police were rewarding him for it. Today is part one of the ‘Tipster Killer’ case and how he used the 'Secret Witness Program' to take himself down.To see photos from today's case, follow us on social media:-Instagram-Facebook-TwitterOr, check out the case blog post on our website. While you're there, let us know what cases you want us to cover in the future. If you're enjoying the show, plea...

    • 35 min
    The murder of DJ Juan Gatti (Stephon Edgerton)

    The murder of DJ Juan Gatti (Stephon Edgerton)

    Send us a Text Message.He was a popular South Georgia Disc Jockey, musician and father of three when he was ambushed outside the local radio station late one Friday night in January of 2012. DJ Juan Gatti… known to friends and family as Stephon Edgerton… was shot three times by an unknown assailant. Stephons' case is still unsolved, but his family believes that several people out there may have information to help bring his killer to justice. If you have any leads or tips on this case, n...

    • 46 min
    The Soquel Massacre

    The Soquel Massacre

    Send us a Text Message.One quiet evening in October 1970, the Live Oak Fire Department in northern California responded to fire at a hilltop mansion. When they got to the back of the house, the chief saw what appeared to be a mannequin floating in the pool. But it wasn't a mannequin. It was a woman who had been gagged and bound. Four more people would be pulled from the pool that night. The opulent home belonged to Soquel Ophthalmologist Dr. Victor Ohta and his wife Virginia, along with ...

    • 49 min
    The murders of Jon, Kay and Abe

    The murders of Jon, Kay and Abe

    Send us a Text Message.A renowned New York City deli owner, a former Hollywood stunt double, and a hardworking migrant living the American dream are all connected by one thing. Join us on this journey that explores the callous killing of famed Second Avenue Deli founder Abe Lebewohl, and motel clerks Kerson "Kay" Praponpoj and Jon Weaver in New York. We'll tell you about the broad daylight murders, how police connected them all, and where the unsolved cases stand now.If you have any informati...

    • 39 min
    The Career Girls Murders: Part 2

    The Career Girls Murders: Part 2

    Send us a Text Message.An over-eager detective, an unethical interrogation and a false confession lands 19-year-old George Whitmore behind bars for the 'Career Girls Murders.' However, the public would soon find out that their real sadistic killer- was still on the loose.Time to dive back into the case that shook New York City in the 1960s. Part 2 covering the double murder of Janice Wylie and Emily Hoffert in their upscale Manhattan apartment explores how a newspaper journalist would finally...

    • 47 min

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5
36 Ratings

36 Ratings

Mjwag19 ,

Here for the victims

Feels like these ladies are too! I cried during the sequel massacre episode. I’m sharing all the unsolved cases you cover…I believe you ladies are going to help solve something and I hope to help too.

wndrgirl ,

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Amazing! A real sleuth here and I love getting down to brass tacks!

B-Roddy ,

Amazing

My friend just turned me on to Two Sleuths! It’s like listening to an episode of dateline…I love how in depth they go sharing their knowledge. Keep the episodes comin ladies!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Blood is Thicker: The Hargan Family Killings
CBS News
CounterClock
audiochuck
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Dateline: True Crime Weekly
NBC News
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery

You Might Also Like

The Vanished Podcast
Wondery
Dark Valley
Crawlspace Media & Glassbox Media
Small Town Dicks
Audio 99
Women and Crime
Cloud10
Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan
Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan
Campus Killings
AbJack Entertainment